Shareholder Awareness Program

Welcome to our blog, our objective is to bring positive change in quality of corporate governance in Indian companies by starting shareholder activism in India!

We will be also sharing experiences on AGM, stock reports and management quality reports.

(click here to download presentation on Shareholder activism)

65th AGM of SBI, online experience and takeaways


65th AGM of SBI


65th AGM of SBI, online experience and key takeaways


Article published as on Tuesday, 14th July, 2020 at 5:00 p.m.   


Here highlights of AGM will be provided.

14th July 3:00p.m the AGM was scheduled
(here is the notice given to exchange)

As I was registered as speaker and was intimated that the AGM is rescheduled at 11: am

Many speakers raised their queries such plans on raising of funds by the bank, some appreciated excellent results some expressed their displeasure no dividend and some also raised queries on the existence of a fake SBI branch opened in Tamil Nadu.

Even I raised my query and asked the management the number of shareholder ineligible to vote due to criteria of minimum 50 shares required to vote, as there are 4 shareholder directors and yet small shareholders are not allowed to vote and requested to make efforts in making voting rights available to everyone.

Coming to the answers given by chairman Rajnish kumar.
(His voice was very low and hence unclear so difficult to make out what he is saying, I have decoded whatever could be understood.)


Highlights and answers to shareholders queries.

NPA recover: last year there was a very good performance and recovery in large account 19/20 total recovery was 22,359 crores of NPA.
And 9250 in written off accounts, this year also efforts continue, hoping that we should be able to repeat our performance.

Capital Adequacy Requirement: policy of SBI to maintain at least 1% above regulatory requirement (12.10% currently).
Growth rate in loan advances is 8%, earlier it was higher, now due to pandemic it is revised.

Yes bank was saved by SBI as per the scheme drawn by Government of India to create financial stability, return on investment will happen in 3 years.

Steps for all round growth, doing very well in deposits growth and advance growth, asset quality front, some difficulties but still able to maintain them,

Fake SBI branch surprised everybody, FIR was launched, first type of mystery for me also, no fraud has happened and no claim  regarding any loss of money

SRA: investment will be done as per and within the guidelines
20,000 crores to MSME distributed will be 100% guaranteed by the govt, they need liquidity due to the covid.

Target of opening 500 branches this year, but due to covid-19 situation target has to be reviewed.

Dividend: due to covid-19 bank has decided to preserve capital, like to watch performance up to September, and then take a decision

About market cap of HDFC bank more than SBI it’s the market perception and also the profits of HDFC are more than the SBI, focus on continuous improvement in the performance and sooner or later I believe that strength will be reflected in the market cap.

Relating to subsidiaries still evaluating whether SBI AMC could be launched in market, all subsidiaries are doing well.

Capital raising, how much amount to raise will be decided.

NIM will be maintained, no further improvement expected
SBI caps future does not seems bright, other subsidiaries well performing,

CSR for covid related done through SBI foundation about 35 crores rupees. 

Provision on bad debt, provisions will be increased to strengthen balance sheet. To enable bank to deal with any shocks arising out of covid-19,

Number of shareholders who were ineligible to vote due to holding less than 50 shares, that number will be shared separately.

(even in last EGM we heard the same thing and numbers are not yet prepared? They seem least interested in providing the data. Another thing Rajnish Kumar is retiring in October this year.)


[Update as on 12th august, 2020 I got reply and here it is

‘In reference to  your question/query  raised  by you in  the AGM of the Bank held on 14.07.2020, we submit reply as under:

Question: How many shareholders were eligible to vote due to criteria of having minimum 50 shares?


Response : 11.83 lac shareholders (out of total 29.48 lac shareholders) were eligible to vote in the Annual General Meeting held on 14.07.2020.’


(I am glad they replied and provided the numbers but it’s disappointing at the same time that out of 29.48 lac shareholders 17.65 lac shareholders were ineligible to vote.)]


Regarding customer service lots of steps have been taken to improve their experience.
(SBI has more than 1.76 lakh customer complains pending at the end of year pg. no.181 of annual report)
Regarding CSR activities they have well defined policies and there are no individual beneficiaries.

He further explained general business points but the voice was not good and hence interpretation was difficult.

My conclusion

SBI AGM was a bit disappointing, as getting key inputs from management remains the key reason for attending AGM’s, as an investor very few important points were known.

Attending SBI AGM was not fruitful for me, it is better to watch management interview on business channels and on internet.

I read somewhere the quote of Radhakishan Damani.
Radhakishan Damani revealed this investment credo when he was asked why he was buying truckloads of HDFC Bank instead of SBI, the PSU behemoth.
Dharavi Dharavi hota hai, aur Peddar Road Peddar Road,
(Source click here: et website & rakeshjhunjhunwala websites)

The meeting continued till approximate 13:45 meaning, 2hours and 45 minutes.

Here is the list of speakers who expressed their query, opinion to the management
Gautam Tiwari
Lekha shah
Ashalata maheshwari
Asoi bhesania
Bharat shah
Mohit parashar
Dinesh Bhatia
Ashish bansal
vinay bhide
Beruz pouredehi
Manisundaram AV
Harsh visharia
Ashok chakravati
Shanti Prakash
Santosh kumar saraf
Chandravati gattani
Shailesh mahadevia
Prakash galava
K. S. balasubramanian
K. ganesh
P. jaichand
Sadanan Sastry
h. s. Patel
I find lot of scope of improvement for SBI!
Previous
Next Post »